Site Navigation
HomeAbout
Services
Testimonials
Contact
Info
FAQ
Carroll’s Treasures Jewelry
"Specializing in Carat-Plus Diamonds!"
About Us
Since opening our doors in 1995, Carroll’s Treasures Jewelry has proudly served Paducah, KY, as a trusted, full-service jewelry store rooted in craftsmanship, quality, and personal service. What began as a local shop has grown into a beloved destination for those who appreciate the beauty and meaning behind every piece of jewelry.
We specialize in high-karat diamonds, vintage and estate jewelry, and custom designs that reflect the unique stories of our customers. Our talented in-house design team works closely with you to create one-of-a-kind pieces for any occasion—whether it's a reimagined heirloom or a brand-new creation. And when it comes to care and maintenance, our on-site repair services are known for their precision, speed, and affordability.
Carroll’s Treasures is a one-stop store for those who appreciate truly unique jewelry. Our showroom features an ever-changing selection of fine jewelry and gifts, ensuring that every visit brings something new to discover. We also offer interest-free financing, making it easier to invest in the jewelry you love without compromise.
Above all, we pride ourselves on creating a shopping experience that exceeds expectations. Whether you're buying, designing, repairing, or simply browsing, we’re here to help you find the perfect piece—and make the moment memorable.
Areas Served
Paducah, KY | Benton, KY | Metropolis, IL | Murray, KY | Mayfield, KY | Grand Rivers, KY | Vienna, IL | Cadiz, KY | Cape Girardeau, MO
Our Professional Associations
- Jewelers of America
Our Certifications
- Certified Senior Management Professional
Languages Spoken
- English
- Spanish
What We Offer
Our Specialties include:
- At Carroll’s Treasures, we specialize in crafting unforgettable jewelry experiences. Whether you're searching for a one-of-a-kind custom piece that reflects your personal style or browsing our ever-changing selection of handpicked designs, you'll find something truly special in our collection. We proudly feature high carat diamonds that radiate brilliance and quality, perfect for marking life’s most meaningful moments. And with interest-free financing available, owning the jewelry of your dreams is more accessible than ever. At Carroll’s, elegance meets individuality—every visit is a treasure hunt.
Our Services include:
- Jewelry Services: At Carroll’s Treasures, we treat your jewelry with the care it deserves. Our on-site services include professional cleaning to restore brilliance, precise sizing and resizing for a perfect fit, and thorough inspections and appraisals to ensure your pieces are in top condition and properly valued. We also assist with insurance replacements, helping you navigate claims with ease. Best of all, many of these services are available while you wait, so you can enjoy convenience without sacrificing quality.
- Custom & Design Services: Your jewelry should be as unique as you are. Our on-site custom design service allows you to collaborate directly with our skilled jewelers to create one-of-a-kind pieces tailored to your style and vision. Whether you're redesigning a family heirloom or dreaming up something entirely new, we bring your ideas to life with craftsmanship and creativity.
- Watch Services: Keep your timepieces ticking with our watch battery replacement service. Quick, reliable, and done on-site, we make it easy to maintain your favorite watches without the hassle of sending them away.
- Gold & Buying Services: Turn your unused gold into immediate value with our gold buying services. We offer instant cash for gold, providing fair and competitive rates right on the spot. Whether you're selling old jewelry or broken pieces, we make the process simple and secure.
- Financing & Specials: We believe everyone should have access to beautiful jewelry. That’s why we offer interest-free financing, making it easier to invest in meaningful pieces without financial strain. Be sure to check out our weekly and monthly specials for exciting deals and limited-time offers on select items and services.
Our Brands include:
- Judith Ripka
Our Products include:
- Navajo Jewelry
- Fine Jewelry
- Heirloom Jewelry
- Costume Jewelry
- Rings
- Earrings
- Necklaces
- Watches
- Bracelets
- Carat-Plus Diamonds
- Vintage Jewelry
- Estate Jewelry
- Engagement and Wedding Rings
- Precious Gems and Stones
- Opals and Pearls
- Yellow, Rose and White Gold
- Sterling Silver and Platinum
- Birthday and Anniversary Gifts
- Valentine’s Day Gifts
- Christmas Gifts
- Gifts for Special Occasions
- Gift Cards Available
- Crown Diamond Premier Dealer
Testimonials
On 9/9/2025
dumpster Witch
had this to say:
I was looking for something extra special for a birthday present for someone who means so much to me.. They had exactly what I wanted!! And the best part it was on sale!! It is being resized for us to.. I love the kind hearted people there!
On 8/26/2025
Detra Coley
had this to say:
Very helpful in finding a way for me to wear and old bracelet without changing the value of the piece. Will definitely go back!
On 7/26/2025
Dustin Christian
had this to say:
I can't recommend this place enough!! Great People, Great Prices!! If you are needing a custom piece made or repaired- stop in and see Autumn and Mike for guaranteed top quality pieces, with professional service and amazing pricing!!
On 6/13/2025
Racheal Mann
had this to say:
I live an hour and a half away now though I grew up in the area. With that being said, I will drive the distance every-time I need anything. I have been treated so respectfully and they have no problem taking time to explain anything that I ask. Highly recommend!
On 3/25/2025
Bill R
had this to say:
The treatment we received was genuine, fair and quite charming. AJ is trustworthy.
Testimonial written by Bill R on this site.
Contact Us
Carroll’s Treasures Jewelry
2600 Park Ave Paducah, KY 42001
Phone: (270) 331-3000
Email: carrollstreasuresjewelry
Across from Robert Cherry Civic Center
Where To Find Us
Follow us on GoogleFollow us on Facebook
Payment Types Accepted
Checks, American Express, Discover, MasterCard, Visa, Debit Cards
Our Hours
Holiday Hours May Vary. Please Call For Details.
Monday: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Tuesday: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Wednesday: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Thursday: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Friday: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Saturday: 10:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Info
Shop Our InventoryFAQ
We specialize in high-karat diamonds, vintage and estate jewelry, and custom-designed pieces. Our collection is always evolving, so there’s something new to discover with every visit.
Can I have a custom piece made?
Absolutely! Our in-house design team can create one-of-a-kind custom jewelry tailored to your style and occasion. Stop by or contact us to start your design journey.
Do you offer jewelry repair?
Yes, we offer on-site jewelry repair at some of the most competitive prices in the area. Many services are available while you wait.
Do you buy gold?
We offer gold buying services and provide immediate cash for gold. Bring in your items for a quick and fair evaluation.
Yes! You can browse our selection of diamonds and fine jewelry through our online showroom. For custom pieces or estate items, we recommend visiting us in-store for the full experience. https://carrollstreasuresjewelry.jewelershowcase.com/
Is everything in-store also available online?
Not always. Our ever-changing inventory, especially vintage and estate pieces, may not be listed online. Visit us in person to explore the full collection.
How do I contact you with questions or to start a custom order?
You can reach us through our website contact form, call us directly, or message us on Facebook. We’re happy to help! You can also explore our customization options here: https://carrollstreasuresjewelry.jewelershowcase.com/browse/3c-collection
Legal
Terms of UsePrivacy Policy